Is it Better to Look at Interest Rates or APYs When Deciding on CDs?

interest rate vs apy

When you’re deciding whether to invest in a Certificate of Deposit (CD), you need to think about the annual percentage yield (APY) and the interest rate. These terms might seem similar, but they’re different and can impact your investment in different ways. So, which one should you focus on more? Let’s break it down.

What is the relationship between interest rate and APY in CD?

The interest rate and APY are important for understanding CD investments. The interest rate is the percentage of interest you earn on your initial deposit. For instance, if a CD has a 3% interest rate, it means you’ll earn 3% of your deposit as interest each year.

The APY is like a big-picture view of your investment. It includes both the interest rate and how often interest is added to your account, called compounding. This shows how much your investment grows over a year, considering both the interest rate and how often it’s compounded, whether daily, monthly, quarterly, or yearly.

The interest rate tells you the basic return you’ll get on your investment, but APY gives a clearer picture by considering how often the interest is compounded. It’s crucial to look at both of these indicators to understand how much your CD investment can grow.

The advantages and disadvantages of looking at the interest rate

Let’s now see if it’s a good idea to look only at the interest rate when considering a CD.


  • Straightforward comparison: The interest rate allows for a simple comparison between different CDs. It makes it easier for investors to identify potentially attractive investment opportunities.
  • Easy understanding: The interest rate serves as a simple and easily understandable metric for assessing the return on investment. It makes it possible for a variety of investors to understand their potential earnings.


  • Neglects compounding effects: The interest rate does not account for the effects of compounding. This makes it harder to determine the true potential of the CD.
  • Potential underestimation of returns: When investors only focus on the interest rate, they’re likely to underestimate the ROI of the CD.

The advantages and disadvantages of looking at the APY

Let’s now look at the advantages and disadvantages of focusing only on the APY.


  • Comprehensive measure: APY looks at both interest rates and the frequency of compounding, allowing it to provide a better view of the ROI.
  • Informed decision-making: APY’s holistic view provides investors with more information about the potential ROI of the CD. This allows investors to make better decisions on the CD they’ll invest in.


  • Complexity: Some investors might have a harder time understanding APY because of its complexity, which could prevent them from using it.
  • Requires financial literacy: APY’s complexity will require investors to have financial literacy. They’ll need to understand interest rates and compounding to know what APY is showing them.

Which is better to look at when considering a CD?

When deciding on a CD, don’t just focus on interest rates or APY. Interest rates are simple to compare, but they may not tell the whole story. APY gives a clearer picture of your investment’s growth potential. While both have drawbacks, it’s wise to consider them before investing. Looking at both factors helps you gauge if your investment will be successful.

What other factors about CDs should be looked at?

Interest rates and APY are crucial when looking at CDs, but they’re not the only things to think about. Other factors are also important for making smart investment choices.

1. Term Length

CDs can last for a few months or many years. Longer CDs often have higher APYs but tie up your money for longer. When picking a CD length, think about your financial goals and how easily you need to access your money.

2. Early Withdrawal fines

If you withdraw money from a CD before it matures, you might face penalties. Investors need to read and understand the terms and conditions regarding these penalties. This helps you know how flexible the CD is and how much you might have to pay if you need to take out money early.

3. Minimum Deposit Requirements

Some CDs need a certain amount of money to open an account. Investors should check if they have enough money to meet these requirements to avoid any problems when opening an account.

4. Renewal Options

When a CD matures, it might renew automatically unless you say otherwise. Investors should check the renewal options and decide if they want to keep the money in the same CD or look for other investment options.

5. Callable CDs

If interest rates go down, callable CDs might limit how much money investors can make. This happens because the bank can cash in the CD before it’s supposed to be done. Investors should think about their investment style and how much risk they’re comfortable with before getting callable CDs.

6. FDIC Insurance

CDs are safest when FDIC-insured banks back them. This means if something happens to the bank like it goes bankrupt, your investment is protected. Always check if the CDs you’re getting have FDIC insurance to keep your money safe.

7. Interest Payment Period

CDs offer different times for interest payments, like monthly, quarterly, or yearly. Choose the payment frequency that fits your needs and how you like to manage your money.

8. Special Promotions and Offers

Sometimes, banks give special deals to encourage people to open CD accounts. These deals might include bonus interest rates or cash rewards. It’s a good idea to check for these offers to get the most out of your CD investment.

Considering these extra factors, along with the interest rate and APY, helps investors make better decisions about CD options. This way, they can figure out if the CDs they’re looking at match their investment plans.

Both the interest rate and APY are important factors

Interest rates and APYs are both important when looking at CDs. But for a full picture of how much your investment could earn, it’s best to focus on APY. By considering both, investors can make smart choices to reach their financial goals.

Scroll to Top